Posted by Josh Dhani on May 9th, 2009 in
Features,
Opinions

The Colts have now signed some new players in free agency and got some new guys from the draft. It brings me to the position battles. A lot of controversial picks but let’s see how it goes. These players will battle for the top, to win their position. Let’s go!
Quarterbacks: 1. Peyton Manning 2. Curtis Painter 3. Jim Sorgi 4. Chris Crane
The Battle: Second-String Quarterback
Who will be the second-stringer. It will never be Peyton Manning, the brain of the quarterbacks in the NFL. It will be between Painter, Sorgi, and Crane.
Painter has been flat-out great in his career, throwing for over 11,000 passing yards and 67 touchdowns. I see him as the second-stringer because he will be mentored greatly by the great Peyton Manning.
Although he might be backing Manning up for the next six years, by the time Manning retires, Painter is in.
Why? Because he has been behind Peyton for so long and will be about 27-31 years old by the time he is starter so he can be the man for the Colts for quite a while.
Then there is Jim Sorgi, who has only thrown for six touchdowns and one interception in his NFL career. He hasn’t been that good as a backup for Manning, and I can see why the Colts got those two other quarterbacks.
Sorgi will try to mentor and will probably be released during the season, but if he isn’t he will be at the third string.
Why? Because if he was in the Painter situation, he will be between 35-37 years old when he is starter. Indy won’t accept having him as starter for a year! That will just be unacceptable. It’s just too messed up that way.
Then there is Chris Crane battling. He won’t stand a chance. He has thrown for eleven touchdowns and 14 interceptions in his college career, which is pretty bad.
He had 10 touchdowns and 13 interceptions last year. He will need more time to improve. And that is why he is at the spot he is as we see in the depth chart.
Running Backs: 1. Joseph Addai 2. Donald Brown 3. Mike Hart 4. Lance Ball 5. Chad Simpson
Two Battles
1. Second String
Ah, the second string. It’ll be Donald Brown vs. Mike Hart for that spot. Mike Hart has one more year of experience but never did anything, only playing one game but only had one carry.
He was injured for the most part. But it will be Donald Brown because he was the first round pick for Indy and he looks to be the man to share the load with Joseph Addai. Hart looks to be something else.
But why Brown? Brown led the league, and it’s College Football of course, and was just spectacular. The Colts could have picked Chris Wells but Donald Brown fits the offense.
He will also be catching some balls, which Mike Hart might not be able to do. And that is why Brown will win this fight. But don’t feel too sorry for Hart, he has something, too!
Read more